Top 7 DIY Cabinet Painting Problems

top 7 issues with diy painted cabinets

🧼 Top 7 DIY Cabinet Painting Problems (and How to Fix Them Before It’s Too Late!)

Are you moving into a home that has painted cabients? Are you tired of looking at a hprroble cabient painting jopb you inherited from somone? Struggling with how to fix a bad cabinet paint job? Are your doors peeling, sticky, or just plain ugly up close? Well Today is for you- Here are the Top 7 DIY Cabinet Painting Problems– what to look for, Here’s what’s really going on—and what to do next to fix them.


🧭 Table of Contents

  1. #1 – Heavy Stipple and Brush Marks
  2. #2 – Fuzzies, Hair, and Surface Contaminants
  3. #3 – Poor Bonding & Peeling Paint
  4. #4 – Low-Quality DIY Paints & Finishes
  5. #5 – Drips, Runs, and Uncontrolled Sheen
  6. #6 – Unremoved Grease and Old Residue
  7. #7 – The True Cost: Sanding Time and Repair Work
    🎯 Takeaways & What to Do If You’re Stuck

#1 – Heavy Stipple and Brush Marks

Problem: You see a bumpy, orange peel-like texture on your cabinets.
Why it happens: Using the wrong roller (or brushing without leveling additives).
Fix: Professional sanding and spraying will restore a smooth, glass-like finish.

cabinets with rolller lines one of theTop 7 DIY Cabinet Painting Problems


🛠 Pro Tip: We use Emerald Urethane or Benjamin Moore Advance for best results—sprayed flat for a flawless finish.


#2 – Fuzzies, Hair, and Surface Contaminants

Problem: Trapped hairs and fuzzy fibers are frozen into the paint like fossils.
Why it happens: Dirty workspace, cheap rollers, or skipping tack cloths.
Fix: Sand it all back down. Then vacuum, wipe, and start with a clean surface.


#3 – Poor Bonding & Peeling Paint

Problem: Paint comes off with the hardware—or flakes off at the corners.
Why it happens: No sanding or bonding primer was used (or the wrong primer).
🎯 What We Look For:

  • Peeling around knobs
  • Paint rubbing off with a fingernail
  • Primer that won’t grip
    Fix: Strip or sand to bare wood, then use GARDZ or a shellac primer like BIN for max adhesion.

#4 – Low-Quality DIY Paints & Finishes

Problem: Rubber-like texture, sticky feel, or overly flat finish.
Why it happens: Cheap or mismatched paints—like Rustoleum kits or latex wall paint.
How to Identify It:

  • Feels like plastic
  • Smudges or marks easily
  • Sheen is blotchy or dull
    Fix: Strip or sand down, prime properly, and spray with pro-grade cabinet enamel.

#5 – Paint Drips, Runs, and Uncontrolled Sheen

Problem: Uneven gloss levels and visible roller/brush patterns in the final coat.
Why it happens: Thick coats, poor lighting, or rushing the process.
Fix: Sand down runs and use a sprayer with even pressure for consistency. Spray flat when possible.


#6 – Unremoved Grease and Old Residue

Problem: Paint is peeling or greasy to the touch.
Why it happens: Cabinets weren’t degreased before painting (yep, it matters).
How You Know:

  • Feels slick or oily
  • Primer bubbles up or flakes off
  • Sandpaper clogs fast
    Fix: Scrub with TSP or a degreaser, then prime with a bonding sealer. We test adhesion before we even pick up a sprayer.

#7 – The True Cost: Sanding Time and Repair Work

Problem: It takes HOURS just to sand one door clean.
Why it happens: Multiple coats of bad paint trap every mistake underneath.
👎 We’ve spent up to 1 hour per door fixing bad paint jobs—vs. 15–20 minutes on clean, well-prepped doors.
Fix: If the prep work exceeds 50% of the job, you’re better off starting from scratch.


🎯 Takeaways & What to Do If You’re Stuck

Here’s the bottom line… We have listed the Top 7 DIY Cabinet Painting Problems- that we have seen. There are other issues that happen, we have made plenty of mistakes ourselves! How they get fixed is important as anything else.

**DIY cabinet painting can work—**but only if you nail the prep, materials, and technique.
If you’re seeing these problems pop up, you’re not alone. We fix them every week.

Here are some things to look for when hiring a cabient painter…Read me!

Your Options:

  • ✅ Keep sanding… and sanding… and sanding…
  • 💰 Hire a pro to strip and spray for a factory finish
  • 🧠 Avoid the mess—do it right the first time with proper primers, degreasers, and sprayers

💬 Ready to Repaint or Redo Your Cabinets?

We offer:

  • Free color consultations
  • 1-year free touch-ups
  • Background-checked painters
  • And a “Give $200, Get $200” referral bonus to sweeten the deal.

📍 Serving homeowners across Huntley, Elgin, Algonquin, South Elgin, Crystal Lake, and surrounding suburbs.

👉 Got painted cabinet regrets? Let’s fix it together.
Request Your Free Estimate

🎥 Check out more real cabinet transformations on our YouTube:
D’Franco Painting & Wallpaper YouTube
🔖 Hashtags: #CabinetPaintFails #CanIGetAPaintQuote #CabinetRedo #DIYDisasterFixes

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Add a splash of color and style to your walls. Book your paint and wallpaper appointment today!